The greatest backdoor of all times might be running right before your eyes.
Earlier today we were quite surprised to discover that our Windows build server rebooted after installing another set of automatic updates. This looked weird, as automated reboots without an administrator’s approval have never been on our security policy. Still, given that we have just upgraded our Windows Server from 2012 to 2016, we believed it to be a misconfiguration issue and embarked on correcting it.
Surprisingly, disabling automated restarts in Windows Server 2016 appeared to be not an easy task. Believe it or not, but unlike it used to be in Server 2012, there is no direct setting in Server 2016 to disable the reboots. You have to employ awkward workarounds, like always having someone logged in, to stop your server from rebooting. Otherwise, it will always reboot automatically, every time a yet another bunch of updates are downloaded and installed.
This looks very worrying. Many server administrators quite reasonably prefer to be in control of reboots of their servers to harmonise them with their working hours, system load, backup and maintenance schedules, and myriad other factors. A mission-critical server that reboots out of the blue in the middle of the night may (and will) lead to all sorts of problems – from a local DoS after failing to complete the restart, to a gaping hole in the company’s network if a third-party IPS fails to co-operate with the updated version of some Windows component.
From a more distant perspective, by removing the possibility to disable automated reboots, Microsoft has acquired a gigantic ‘power switch’, which it can use to force thousands of servers across the world into rebooting by simply sending them a specific ‘update’ package. This puts the owners of those servers into an uncomfortable position of hostages. Even if we do believe in good intentions of the Seattle company, how can we be sure that someone won’t break into their update delivery environment one day, and use the legitimate update procedure to send to all the Windows servers out there a deadly restart command?
Image credit: pngtree.com